Marianne in Therapy » JASNA
I am confused about what happened when Willoughby showed Marianne his . It was quite daring to portray an unmarried couple being alone unchaperoned. But there was no such option in her day, nor does a therapeutic relationship . Even when Marianne believes that Willoughby loves her and will be faithful, she is but the parental guidance so crucial to teenagers.4 (Even if teens often reject . Thoughts on ambiguity in dating and mating . The nature of Marianne and Willoughby's relationship becomes the subject of an argument between Elinor and their mother, Mrs. Dashwood. Here's some modern advice.
Can you be more specific? I'm not sure I've seen a writer arguing in favor of Lydia's materialism anywhere; who does that? One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. Elton does not talk to Miss Fairfax as she speaks of her. We all know the difference between the pronouns he or she and thou, the plainest-spoken amongst us; we all feel the influence of a something beyond common civility in our personal intercourse with each other -- a something more early implanted.
We cannot give any body the disagreeable hints that we may have been very full of the hour before. We feel things differently.
That's just human, which we have to acknowledge that Jane Austen was. In that subliminal sense, this passage covertly speaks to ANOTHER way in which JA's world was unfairly organized against the interests of women, when women's transgressive sexual behavior has been subjected to a harsh and unforgiving moral judgment, by giving such women choices between abortion, prostitution, or, at best, governessing.
How utterly brilliant of JA to speak on two levels about the same subject, unfairness to women. Few passages more beautifully exemplify that brilliance of dual construction. Willoughby treats her very coldly and is obviously paying attention to another lady.
What About Marianne? Does She Not Deserve Love? | Austen Authors
This greatly upsets Marianne who has to be taken home early. The next day, Marianne receives a letter from Willoughby in which he informs her in very cold and distant terms that his affections have long been engaged elsewhere and he is sorry if she ever mistakenly thought otherwise. He also returns all her letters and the lock of hair that she had "so obligingly bestowed upon him".
Marianne is thrown into utter despair. Elinor thinks that Willoughby has broken an engagement with Marianne, but she explains that they were never engaged. Elinor attempts in vain to afford Marianne some consolation, and she tells her beloved sister to think of her family and to exert herself through this difficult interval of sorrow. At the ball it is revealed that Mr. Willoughby's scandal[ edit ] Colonel Brandon, a friend of Elinor and Marianne, explains the reason for Willoughby's abrupt change of heart.
It turns out that Willoughby had seduced the Colonel's year-old ward, Beth, then abandoned her though she was pregnant.
Brandon finds her, but in doing so Willoughby's actions are revealed to the world. When his aunt learns of the scandal, she demands that he makes amends to Beth. When he refuses, she expels him from her estate and disinherits him, leaving him penniless and with many debts.
It is at this point that he flees to London in search of a rich wife. Elinor tells Marianne about this in order that she see what a selfish person Willoughby is. Marianne catches cold[ edit ] Marianne is so distressed by Willoughby's rejection that she becomes sick.
When she is caught in a storm with an injured leg, she is rescued by the dashing young Mr. Willoughby who happened to be passing by and carries her safely home.
What About Marianne? Does She Not Deserve Love?
Marianne is charmed and swept off her feet by his physical appearance and gallant manners. Willoughby courts her and leads her to believe he is deeply in love. She is heartbroken when she later learns about his bad reputation with women and his engagement to a wealthy woman for her money.
Marianne discovers that a lover's character, capacity for real affection and personal values are a far truer and more lasting basis for successful relationship than external appearances. She matures and marries Brandon, a 37 year old Colonel who loves her deeply. HomeVideos offers interesting movie reviews of Sense and Sensibility.